How to Respond to “I’m Praying for You” After Leaving Religion

If you’ve stepped away from a faith tradition—or are in the middle of religious deconstruction—you’ve probably heard this phrase more times than you can count:

“I’m praying for you.”

Sometimes it’s said with genuine love. Other times it lands like a subtle judgment or an unwanted reminder of beliefs you’re trying to leave behind.

One of the most common questions I hear from clients deconstructing their faith is how to respond to ‘I’m praying for you’ in a way that feels respectful but honest.

Whether it brings up awkwardness, anger, grief, or confusion, you’re not alone. Let’s talk about what this phrase really means, why it can feel so complicated, and how to respond in a way that feels right for you.

Why “I’m Praying for You” Can Feel So Loaded To someone still in a religious community, offering to pray might feel like a natural, caring response. But when you’ve experienced religious trauma, spiritual abuse, or are healing from a high-control religious environment, those words can bring up a flood of emotions:

Shame: “Do they think something’s wrong with me?”
Frustration: “Why can’t they respect where I’m at now?”
Sadness: “I used to believe this too, but now it feels empty or painful.”
Discomfort: “I don’t want to have this conversation again.”

It can feel like your journey is being minimized or spiritualized away—as if your boundaries or lived experiences don’t matter as much as their beliefs.

What They Might Be Trying to Say

It’s okay to acknowledge that not every “I’m praying for you” is an attack. Sometimes, people genuinely don’t know what else to say. This phrase might be their way of expressing care, worry, or concern—even if it lands poorly.

That said, your interpretation of it matters. If it feels invalidating, performative, or boundary-crossing, you’re allowed to protect your peace.

Three people sitting outdoors, engaged in a lively conversation. Background includes lush green foliage. Casual and relaxed mood.

How to Respond to "I'm Praying For You": 5 Options That Honor Where You’re At

Here are a few ways you can respond—ranging from neutral to direct—depending on your relationship with the person and your emotional bandwidth.

1. Neutral and Polite

If it feels easier to sidestep the conversation:

“Thanks for thinking of me.”

“I appreciate the kind intention.”

This keeps things cordial without inviting a deeper theological debate.

2. Lightly Redirecting

If you want to acknowledge their care but gently set a boundary:

“I know that’s how you show love—thank you. I’m exploring support in other ways right now.” “I appreciate your heart. I’m focusing on things that feel grounding for me these days.”

This affirms their intent while making space for your journey.

3. Setting a Clear Boundary

If you need to be more direct:

“I know prayer is meaningful for you, but I’m in a different place with my beliefs and would prefer we connect in other ways.” “I’d appreciate support that doesn’t involve prayer right now—it helps me feel more seen where I’m at.”

You’re not being rude. You’re being honest—and that’s brave.

4. Invite a Different Kind of Support

If you sense that someone truly wants to support you but isn’t sure how, this can be a chance to gently invite them to meet you where you are—without debating faith.

“Thanks for thinking of me—want to hear what’s actually been helpful for me lately?” “I know you care. If you’re open to it, I’d love to share what kind of support feels most meaningful to me right now.”

“I appreciate the intention behind that. I’ve been finding comfort in [therapy, nature, writing, etc.]—it’s helping me reconnect to myself.”

This approach honors the relationship while steering it toward more mutual understanding. It also gives the other person a way to be present for you that feels more aligned with your values and needs.

5. Silence Is Also a Response You don’t have to respond at all. If the comment is unsolicited or feels like spiritual pressure, you can choose not to engage. An explanation is not owed.

Give Yourself Permission to Feel What Comes Up You don’t have to feel guilty for how this phrase lands with you. Whether it brings up irritation, grief, or even longing for something you once found comforting, your reaction is valid.

Leaving a faith system often means renegotiating how we relate to language, family, identity, and belonging. These are big, emotional topics—and you’re doing hard, important work by honoring your truth.

Cozy scene of a person in a sweater, holding a book and mug, sitting by a snowy window. Gray socks and a fluffy blanket add warmth.

Final Thoughts

You don’t owe anyone a perfect response. You don’t have to educate everyone. And you don’t have to soften your truth to make others comfortable.

If “I’m praying for you” feels like a reminder of pain or distance, it’s okay to protect your space. If it feels neutral or even comforting, that’s okay too. The point is: you get to choose.

Your healing matters. And you’re allowed to rewrite the rules for what support looks like in your life now. If you think you'd benefit from more support, let's connect.

Schedule a Call