top of page

When Love Equals Obedience: How Religious Anxiety Affects Relationships

Writer: Samantha FotiSamantha Foti

Have you ever felt like love and obedience were tangled together? In some religious environments, the line between love and obedience can become blurred. You might have been taught that to show love for God, your family, or even your partner, you had to follow the rules without question.


While love and obedience are two very different things, they’re sometimes used interchangeably in high-control religious settings. When this happens, it can lead to confusion, anxiety, and struggles in relationships.


In this post, we’ll explore how religious anxiety—the fear, guilt, or self-doubt that comes from strict religious teachings—can affect your relationships. We’ll also talk about what healing looks like when you’re ready to separate love from obedience and build connections based on trust, authenticity, and mutual respect.


When Love and Obedience Get Blurred


In many religious communities, love is described as deep devotion, trust, and connection—all positive and fulfilling emotions. But in high-control environments, love can also be closely tied to obedience and compliance. You might hear messages like:


  • “If you love God, you’ll follow His commands without question.”

  • “A good spouse shows love by submitting to their partner’s authority.”

  • “True believers obey without doubt or hesitation.”


Over time, these messages can create the belief that being loved—or worthy of love—means being perfectly obedient. This can make relationships feel confusing and anxiety-inducing, especially when you want to express your own needs, desires, or boundaries.


How Religious Anxiety Shows Up in Relationships


Let’s break down how this blurring of love and obedience can affect romantic relationships:


1. Fear-Based Commitment

When love and obedience are intertwined, you might find yourself staying in a relationship out of fear rather than genuine connection. You may worry that leaving will disappoint your family, anger God, or mark you as a failure.


You might think:

  • “If I leave, it means I’m not loyal or loving enough.”

  • “What if I’m being tested, and leaving is a sign of weak faith?”

  • “Good people don’t give up on relationships, right?”


2. Suppressing Your Needs and Boundaries


When love is tied to obedience, it can feel wrong or selfish to express your own needs. You might believe that being a good partner means always accommodating your partner’s desires, even when it doesn’t feel right to you.


This can show up as:

  • Saying "yes" when you really want to say "no" to avoid conflict.

  • Feeling guilty for needing space, support, or independence.

  • Prioritizing your partner’s happiness over your own well-being.


Healing from Religious Anxiety in Relationships


Healing is about untangling love from obedience. Love doesn’t require perfection or blind compliance—it thrives in relationships where both partners feel safe to be their authentic selves.


3. Redefining Love Beyond Obedience


Love isn’t about following rules or meeting impossible expectations. It’s about connection, mutual respect, and choice. Healthy relationships are built on:


  • Open communication—where both people feel heard and valued.

  • Respect for individuality—where both partners can express their needs and boundaries without fear.

  • Emotional safety—where love isn’t conditional on obedience, but based on trust and acceptance.


Conclusion: You Deserve Love Without Fear





If you’ve been taught that love and obedience go hand in hand, it’s understandable that relationships might feel confusing or overwhelming. But love doesn’t require constant compliance—it thrives on trust, respect, and freedom to be yourself.


Whether you’re questioning your beliefs, reevaluating a relationship, or trying to understand your anxiety, know that healing is possible. Therapy can help you untangle the messages that have kept you stuck and guide you toward relationships that feel safe, fulfilling, and true to who you are.




 
 
 

Comments


© 2022 by Behavioral Health Counseling LLC | Revised 2025

bottom of page